Saturday 20 December 2014

40 Abbott and Costello


First  watched  : Uncertain

This  was  introduced  to   BBC1   on   Monday  1  June  1970  as  part  of  the  re-jigging  of  the  teatime  schedule  to  accommodate  the  1970  World  Cup  ( of  which  I  have  no  recollection  whatsoever ). It  proved  that  not  everything  Hanna-Barbera  did  turned  to  gold.

These  five  minutes  shorts  were  part  of  a  series  of  cartoon  resurrections  of  comedy  greats ; Laurel  and  Hardy  got  the  same  treatment. Of  course  the  problem  was  that  not  only  were  these  guys  mostly  dead, so  were  the  people  who  wrote  for  them  so  what  you  have  here  is  two  cartoon  representations  of  well-loved  figures  dropped  into  the  lamest  of  scenarios - usually  "Lou  Costello"  yelling  as  he  ran  away  from  some  dangerous  beast - without  any  hint  of  why  people  loved  them  so  much  in  the  first  place.

What  makes  this  one  particularly  sad  is  that  Bud  Abbott  was  so  hard  up by  this  time  ( 1968-69 )  he  actually  agreed  to  come  in  and  do  his  "own"  voice  on  the  wretched  thing. And  that  wasn't  the  worst  of  it. Lou  Costello  had  died  in  1959  so  his  voice  was  performed  by  Stan  Irwin,  a  nightclub  manager  and  friend  to  both  men. Costello  had  developed  a  high  pitched  yelping  tone  in  their  radio  days  when  the  pace  of  their  repartee  made  it  difficult  for  some  listeners  to  tell  them  apart.  It  worked  for  him  but   Irwin's  exaggeration  of   the  voice  combined  with  his  wooden  delivery  make  it  excruciating,  unbearable  even  in  5  minute  doses.

It  disappeared  from  our  screens  in  1971  and  good  riddance !

No comments:

Post a Comment